If you’re a longtime fan of the Bachelor Franchise, you may recognize Susie from The Bachelor Season 26, where she famously rejected Clayton Echard’s proposal. By the time the finale and After the Final Rose special aired, the two had gotten back together. But they announced their breakup on Instagram in September 2022.

Three weeks into Bachelor in Paradise Season 10 and fans have already been treated to tons of juicy drama, but most of it has come from former couple Justin Glaze and Susie Evans's awkward reunion. Susie's unexpected entrance into paradise during Week 2 flipped things upside down for Justin,