The facial expression on some creators' YouTube thumbnails ... indicating that closed-mouth thumbnails are in and shocked face thumbnails are out. I closed my mouth on all my thumbnails and ...

As expected, sports fans saw Prescott's shocked face and immediately ran to make memes of his shocked expression.

Pikachu’s gobsmacked expression ... characters were shocked by this turn of events. And Pikachu—visible in the bottom right corner of the screen—is seen making the face from the meme.