I'm kind of old man dad. My kids are 4 and 2½, so to share... I've always known [Tina Fey's] kids, and to get to share my family with her was a really special thing," Forte tells PEOPLE.

And while Meyers fights to maintain a neutral face, Forte looks him in his eyes and commends him on being a great dad, "I'm so proud of you." Rather than simply offering a silly voice or a bit ...